Up to Other Free Picks

posted February 4, 2009 at 15:00 EST in Other Free Picks

The Oscars Best Actor - Two Horse Race between Rourke and Penn

Bookmark and Share by Charles Jay

In the Best Actor category there are two icons who are fast becoming legends, as well as two veteran character actors looking for their day in the sun, and finally, occupying the favorite's role, a comeback story that might have its triumphant culmination when the envelope is opened.

Let's take a look at the odds, as they are posted at BetUS Sportsbook:

To Win Best Actor

Mickey Rourke - The Wrestler -120

Sean Penn - Milk +130

Frank Langella - Frost/Nixon +650

Brad Pitt - The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button +1500

Richard Jenkins - The Reader +2500

MICKEY ROURKE (-120 at BetUS) had what Roger Ebert called "the role of his lifetime" in "The Wrestler" and indeed it is a role unlike anything he's done to date. I was not blown away by the story told in this film, although I must say that Rourke, who won the Golden Globe, really stood out. And I never doubted that he was capable of a comeback like this. He has acknowledged that this role mirrors the arc his career had taken, prior to the point where Darren Aronofsky approached him with the "Wrestler" script. This would be the best "comeback" story at this year's Oscars, and he has been campaigning for it, in a way that distinguishes him from the "old" Rourke. Some voters probably still have something against him, and that is the thing that might put him in second place in the end. Sean Penn is a director. Directors can hire actors. Actors vote. See what I mean?

A quick bit of trivia, in the way of disclosure: in 1991, when I was doing some television and Rourke had adopted professional boxing as a sort of hobby, I was actually negotiating with his manager to fight him. How's THAT for some name-dropping? The story made it to the local papers and onto the wire service. Here's how I was quoted in the South Florida Sun Sentinel: "I'd probably have to rate Mickey as a 2-to-1 favorite, based on his edge in experience. But that's OK. I like being the underdog." Hahahaha! They also reported that I had quit smoking as part of my training (true, at the time). Even if the bout had come off, I doubt I could have busted Mickey's face up enough to make it look like it did in "The Wrestler," though.

SEAN PENN (+130 at BetUS) played a role in "Milk" that was more substantial than the one he won the Oscar for in "Mystic River." The film was virtually ignored by the Golden Globes, but the Academy has given it eight nominations. Somewhere along the line it has to get honored. Obviously this is a group of voters who appreciated the movie a lot more. Penn is the only previous winner in this category, and it should be neck-and-neck between him and his old friend Rourke for this award.

FRANK LANGELLA (+650 at BetUS) plays Richard Nixon, who along with Harvey Milk, are the only real-life characters portrayed by Best Actor nominees. The long-time stage and screen actor, who gained plaudits for his lead role in "Starting Out in the Evening" last year, won a Tony award for this same role on Broadway. And to think he almost didn't get the role in the film. At 71, he is the oldest nominee in the category and someone who has an outside chance at best.

BRAD PITT (+1500 at BetUS) is a tricky one to figure out. He hasn't exactly been singled out by critics for his work as the lead player in this piece. However, his film, "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" has garnered 13 nominations, which means there is definitely something Academy voters like very much about it. Maybe there's a place or two it can be recognized elsewhere on the Oscar menu. Most likely he and wife Angelina Jolie won't be taking that walk up the steps. I do think that at 15/1, he's priced too high.

RICHARD JENKINS (+2500 at BetUS) is a great character actor who got a rare leading role in "The Visitor" and parlayed it into an Oscar nomination. It was an independent film, not seen by many, and it hurts him, obviously. Jenkins has been in a lot of films - he has worked with other nominees like Josh Brolin ("Flirting With Disaster") and Brad Pitt (this past year's "Burn After Reading") and probably some others. I even worked with him once when I was an extra on "Miami Vice" (yes, some more name-dropping). For him, this is a springboard to getting more substantial character roles and the occasional lead in a good independent flick.

The winner? Well, because he is getting a price, and because I consider it relatively even at the top, I would say the better value play here is Sean Penn.

(Charles Jay strolls along the red carpet - at his home - and also contributes to the BetUS Locker Room)

Call toll free: 1 888 51 BETUS (23887)